How To Select A Website Redesign Company

Don't have time to read this? Schedule a 30-minute call and we will walk you through exactly how this applies to your business. Book a call

Key Takeaways

• The selection process for a redesign company should start with your requirements, not their portfolio. What your project needs filters the candidate pool before any evaluation begins.
• Technical capability, communication quality, and project management discipline matter more than design aesthetics. Aesthetics can be directed. Process cannot be borrowed.
• References from past clients are the most underused evaluation tool. A single 15-minute call with a former client reveals more than two hours of sales presentations.
• The contract scope is part of the selection. What the company will not do is as important as what they say they will.

Selecting a website redesign company is not like buying a product. You are not evaluating a finished item. You are evaluating a team's ability to execute a complex project over several months, with your business as the subject.

Getting this decision right requires a structured process, not gut feeling and good vibes in the first meeting.

Step 1: Define What You Are Actually Selecting For

Before looking at a single company, write down what your redesign project specifically requires.

Requirements to document:

• What is the primary business problem this redesign solves?
• Which pages or sections are changing, and which are staying?
• Does the URL structure need to change? If so, who is responsible for the redirect map?
• Are you migrating platforms? From which CMS to which?
• What integrations must work on launch day? (CRM, e-commerce, scheduling, payments)
• Who on your team has final approval authority?
• What is your target launch date, and is it fixed or flexible?
• What is your content plan? Are you providing copy, or does the company write it?

These requirements are the filter. A company that specializes in Shopify e-commerce builds is not a good fit for a B2B SaaS site with complex integrations and a critical SEO transfer. Knowing your requirements before you start looking prevents you from getting sold by a portfolio that is not relevant to your situation.

Step 2: Build a Short List

Once your requirements are clear, build a short list of three to six companies that plausibly meet them.

Where to find candidates:

• Referrals from peers who have completed similar projects
• Clutch or G2 listings filtered by project type and budget range
• Google searches for companies that rank for redesign-related terms (ranking suggests they understand SEO)
• LinkedIn searches for agencies in your industry or region

Quick filters to apply before outreach:

• Do they have case studies with measurable outcomes, not just before-and-after screenshots?
• Do they publish any substantive content about their process or methodology?
• Do they list specific services and platforms rather than generic "we do everything" claims?
• Does their portfolio include projects at a similar scope to yours?

A company that does not meet basic criteria here is unlikely to improve in a proposal. Keep the short list to companies worth your evaluation time.

Step 3: The Discovery Call

The initial call with each company on your short list should be a mutual evaluation. You are learning about them. They should be learning about you.

A company worth considering asks questions like:

• What are your business goals for this redesign?
• Who is the primary audience for the new site?
• What is working on your current site that we should preserve?
• How does organic search factor into your business?
• What does the approval process look like on your side?
• What has gone wrong on past web projects you have been involved in?

A company that spends the discovery call mostly presenting their work and capabilities is more interested in selling than in understanding. Both are necessary. The balance matters.

Red flags in the discovery call:

• They promise specific outcomes before understanding your current situation
• They cannot describe their process in concrete terms when asked
• They do not ask anything about your current site's SEO or traffic
• They pivot quickly to price without understanding scope

Step 4: Request Proposals From Your Top Three

After discovery calls, narrow to three and request formal proposals.

Tell each company explicitly what your proposal should include. This creates a standard so you can compare them fairly.

What to ask each company to include:

• Project phases with named deliverables and timelines
• What they need from you at each stage and when
• How they handle SEO during the redesign (redirect map, meta migration, staging validation)
• Number of revision rounds per deliverable type
• What is explicitly out of scope
• Post-launch support period and terms
• Total investment with payment terms

A proposal that omits scope boundaries, revision terms, or SEO handling is telling you those items will create problems later. Strong companies include them because they know from experience that ambiguity becomes conflict.

Step 5: Evaluate Each Proposal on the Same Criteria

Do not evaluate proposals based on how well-designed the PDF is. Evaluate them on substance.

Evaluation criteria:

Score each proposal on these criteria before letting price influence the comparison.

Step 6: Check References

This step is skipped more often than any other, and it is the one that provides the most reliable signal.

Ask each finalist company for two or three references from projects similar to yours. Then call them.

Questions to ask references:

• Did the project launch on time? If not, what caused the delay and how did the company handle it?
• Were there scope or budget changes during the project? How were they managed?
• How was communication throughout? Did you always know where things stood?
• Were there any post-launch issues? How quickly were they resolved?
• Would you hire this company again? Why or why not?

A reference that hesitates on the "would you hire them again" question tells you something. A reference that immediately says yes and can tell you specifically why tells you something different.

For guidance on what to watch for when evaluating vendors, the agency red flags resource covers the patterns that consistently predict poor project outcomes.

Step 7: Evaluate the Contract Before Signing

The contract is part of the selection. Read it before you sign it.

Key contract elements to review:

• Who owns the work? You should own all deliverables, not just the right to use them.
• What are the change order terms? What triggers an additional cost and what is the process?
• What is the payment schedule? Front-heavy payment schedules favor the agency; milestone-based schedules protect the client.
• What happens if you need to pause or cancel the project?
• What is the post-launch warranty period and what does it cover?
• How are disputes handled?

A company that is reluctant to discuss contract terms or pushes back on reasonable client protections is not a company that expects to deliver satisfactory work.

Webflow Development Services

Webflow Experts On-Demand

Whether you're starting fresh or need a full revamp—we create fast, modern Webflow sites built for growth.

Let's talk

The Final Decision

After completing this process, the right choice becomes relatively clear.

You are selecting the company that:

1. Understood your requirements before pitching solutions
2. Proposed a specific, bounded scope with named deliverables
3. Described a real SEO handling process, not a generic commitment
4. Has references who would hire them again without hesitation
5. Has a contract that protects both parties fairly

Price is a consideration, but a company that does the right things costs less in the end than a company that cuts corners on discovery, SEO, and QA, regardless of their headline number.

LOW/CODE Agency is a leading AI product team for SMBs and startups. We have helped clients including Medtronic, Zapier, and Sotheby's through every phase of this decision.

For teams also weighing whether to hire internally, the agency versus in-house comparison addresses the organizational trade-offs before you begin vendor evaluation.

Website projects start at $10,000+. Let's talk