How To Hire Someone To Redesign My Website

Don't have time to read this? Schedule a 30-minute call and we will walk you through exactly how this applies to your business. Book a call

Key Takeaways

• The hiring decision depends on your project's scope, timeline, budget, and how much internal oversight you can realistically provide.
• Agencies offer structured processes and full-team coverage. Freelancers offer flexibility and lower overhead. In-house teams offer control and continuity.
• Mismatching the hire to the project scope is the most common and most expensive hiring mistake in web redesign.
• Before you write a job post or send an RFP, define the deliverables, the timeline, and the decision-maker on your side. Every hiring conversation gets easier and more accurate with those three things documented.

Hiring someone to redesign your website sounds simpler than it is.

The field includes solo freelancers who can complete a project in four weeks and charge $5,000. It includes boutique agencies that take six months and charge $80,000. It includes full-time in-house hires, offshore dev shops, and everything between.

The right choice depends entirely on what your project actually is. Here is how to figure that out, then hire for it correctly.

Step 1: Define the Project Before Looking for a Hire

Most hiring mistakes happen before the first conversation.

Teams begin searching for a web designer or agency before they have defined what they need built. Without a clear scope, every candidate looks plausible and every proposal is hard to compare.

Define these before you hire anyone:

• What pages are changing, and what pages are staying the same?
• Is the platform (CMS) changing? If so, from what to what?
• Who is writing the content? You, the hire, or a combination?
• What integrations must work at launch: CRM, email, payments, bookings, forms?
• Is SEO protection required? Do you have organic traffic that must be preserved through the transition?
• Who approves decisions on your team, and how many approval rounds are realistic?
• What is the target launch date, and is it firm?

This document does not need to be long. It needs to be complete. Every question you answer here saves you multiple conversations and proposal revisions later.

Step 2: Choose the Right Type of Hire

Once you know what you are building, match the project to the type of hire.

Agency

Best for: Projects requiring coordinated expertise across design, development, SEO, content strategy, and QA. Projects with complex integrations, significant page counts, or platform migrations.

Strengths:

• Structured process with defined phases and deliverables
• Multiple disciplines covered under one contract
• Project management is included
• Accountability through a firm, not an individual

Considerations:

• Higher minimum investment than freelancers
• Less flexibility to make scope changes mid-project
• Senior talent in the pitch room is not always on your project day to day

Minimum scope where agency makes sense: 50+ pages, CMS migration, or any project where SEO protection and complex integration management are required.

Freelancer

Best for: Smaller scope projects, clearly defined deliverables, teams with strong internal project management capability and time to oversee.

Strengths:

• Lower overhead and more flexible pricing
• Direct access to the person doing the work
• Faster for small, well-scoped projects

Considerations:

• Single point of failure if the freelancer becomes unavailable
• One person rarely covers design, development, and SEO with equal depth
• Requires more client oversight and project management on your side

Minimum scope where freelancer makes sense: Under 20 pages, minimal integration requirements, redesign rather than platform migration, client team has strong web project experience.

In-House Hire

Best for: Organizations with ongoing web work beyond a single redesign. Companies that need continuous iteration and cannot afford per-project costs for every change.

Strengths:

• Full ownership and context continuity
• No project boundary constraints
• Deep familiarity with the brand and systems over time

Considerations:

• Slowest to deploy for a single project (hiring timeline adds months)
• One hire rarely covers every discipline needed for a full redesign
• Highest total cost when you include salary, benefits, and overhead

Most businesses do not need a full-time in-house hire to complete one redesign. The in-house model makes more sense for teams with sustained web development needs beyond the redesign event.

Step 3: Write a Clear Brief or RFP

Whether you are hiring an agency or a freelancer, a written brief produces better candidates and better proposals than a verbal summary.

A strong design brief covers:

1. Company background (one paragraph: what you do and who you serve)
2. Project purpose: what problem this redesign solves, in business terms
3. Scope: what is being redesigned and what is out of scope
4. Technical requirements: CMS, integrations, hosting platform, languages if relevant
5. SEO requirements: do you have organic traffic to protect? If yes, who owns the redirect map?
6. Content plan: who is writing copy and when will it be ready?
7. Timeline: target launch date and any fixed milestones
8. Budget range: a range is more effective than asking vendors to "come in with their best number"
9. Decision-maker: who approves decisions and how many people are in the approval chain

A brief that is honest about budget produces proposals designed to fit your actual constraints, not aspirational proposals you will reject.

For the structured agency evaluation approach, the how to choose a website redesign agency process applies after your brief is ready.

Step 4: Evaluate Candidates on Process, Not Just Portfolio

A portfolio shows what someone can produce. It does not show how they produce it, how they communicate when things go wrong, or how they handle scope that evolves mid-project.

Questions that reveal process quality:

• "Walk me through how you handled a project where the scope changed significantly after work began."
• "How do you handle SEO during a website redesign?"
• "What happens if I am not happy with the first design direction?"
• "Who on your team would actually be doing my project day-to-day?"

Look for specificity in the answers. Generic answers ("we communicate proactively") predict generic execution. Specific answers ("we build in a mid-project scope check at the end of the design phase and handle additions through a written change order") predict reliable execution.

Step 5: Structure the Contract to Protect Both Parties

Once you have selected a candidate, the contract scope matters as much as the price.

Non-negotiable contract terms:

• Work-for-hire clause: you own all deliverables
• Defined revision rounds per phase: limit the number, not the depth of feedback
• Milestone-based payment schedule: tie payments to deliverables, not calendar dates
• Change order process: any scope addition is documented in writing with a cost before work begins
• Post-launch support: define how long and what is covered
• Launch dependencies: define what happens if your content or approvals are late

A contract that is thin on these elements will generate conflict as soon as the project hits friction. And most projects do, at some point.

Webflow Development Services

Webflow Experts On-Demand

Whether you're starting fresh or need a full revamp—we create fast, modern Webflow sites built for growth.

Let's talk

The Decision in One Question

If you are still uncertain which type of hire to make, ask yourself this:

"If this goes wrong, do I have the time and expertise to identify the problem, manage the recovery, and ensure the outcome gets fixed?"

If yes, a freelancer is a reasonable option and you can save money with good oversight.

If no, pay for an agency with a structured process, defined accountability, and multiple disciplines on the project.

The premium for a well-run agency is not for their design. It is for their process. And when your website is generating business, their process is what protects the investment.

LOW/CODE Agency is a leading AI product team for SMBs and startups. We work with companies that want a structured process and a team accountable for outcomes, not just deliverables.

The freelance vs. agency trade-offs covers what to consider if you are weighing a solo hire against an agency engagement.

Website projects start at $10,000+. Book a 30-minute call